Rebel Commando - Kenner - Vintage Return of the Jedi (1983)
Return to the Main Jedi Temple Archives Home Page

Legacy Collection

Duel On Mustafar - LC - Battle Packs

Name: Duel On Mustafar
Collection: Legacy Collection
Number: N/A (Battle Packs)
Source: Revenge Of The Sith
Availability: November 2009
License: Hasbro

Review_DuelMustafarRedo01 Review_DuelMustafarRedo02 Review_DuelMustafarRedo03 Review_DuelMustafarRedo04
Review_DuelMustafarRedo05 Review_DuelMustafarRedo06 Review_DuelMustafarRedo07 Review_DuelMustafarRedo08
Review_DuelMustafarRedo09 Review_DuelMustafarRedo10 Review_DuelMustafarRedo11 Review_DuelMustafarRedo12

On the planet Mustafar, Darth Vader and Obi-Wan Kenobi face each other in their penultimate battle. They are both gifted with the Force and skilled in the art of lightsaber combat. As rivers of molten lava flow around them, the Sith apprentice and the Jedi Master engage in a brutal contest that has tragic consequences for the entire galaxy.

The Duel On Mustafar Battle Packs set slightly exceeded our expectations. And we are not impressed because of how Hasbro reinvented four older figures, but because the presentation makes them look better than they are. This isn't a dig but rather actually a compliment to Hasbro on how a little extra thought in presentation can make old things relatively new again. You may or may not be of the opinion that three out of the four figures in this set are what we consider definitive (for the moment) and the fourth is an OK sculpt with an OK likeness (but unfortunate and terrible action feature). So overall, there are pretty great figures in this set. Loosely based on a pivotal scene in Star Wars Episode III: Revenge Of The Sith, the Duel On Mustafar package is a great selection of main characters even though you may likely have all four by now (and multiple times too). Let's be up front and clear as can be from the very beginning of this review: this set is one to definitely keep boxed. If you are a packaged collector, you have the opportunity to add a very nice piece into your collections because this set looks spectacular through the window box. The figures are posed very nicely in the package and stand in front of a beautiful background where the orange lava follows the silhouette of the figures. It is quite a visual and grabs your attention. We rarely talk about packaging, let alone rave about it in our reviews, but in this case we will make an exception because this set stands out and we think it is worthy of comment.

Moving along to the figures, Darth Vader (Anakin Skywalker – yes it drives us crazy too – Darth Vader is a guy with a helmet and in a black suit, not some kid who played Anakin Skywalker) and Obi-Wan Kenobi are repacks of 2008's TAC figures with the slightest of paint changes (not enough to qualify as a repaint by any means). Both Obi=Wan Kenobi (08 01) and Darth Vader (08 02) are fine figures to begin with so it's great Hasbro chose good figures to include here. Most noticeably different are the eyebrows and scar on Anakin and the dark layered shirt on Obi-Wan Kenobi. It seems as if Hasbro is unable to guarantee exactly the same figures coming our way if they are made during different time periods. Factories seem to make unintentional changes here and there no doubt due to what materials are available on hand when it is time to make more figures (including slightly different shades of paint). But even the vintage line has paint differences, many of which we feel the collecting public as whole still are not even aware. Moving along, Emperor Palpatine is the same old figure from 2005's Revenge Of The Sith line. And yes, it comes with the same old action figure and silly projectiles that was designed with kids in mind. It is a disappointing addition to this set is the only figure that has aged poorly even in such a short time. The Shock Trooper is a repack of the 2007 TAC Shock Trooper Saga Legends figure. It is not a repack of the figure included in the 2006 TSC Skirmish In The Senate Battle Packs set. This Shock Trooper's helmet parallel lines deco (right above the visor) and on the "cheeks" were not far enough (space-wise) from each other (they looked as if they were almost bleeding together). But Hasbro corrected this issue starting with the 2007 TAC Saga Legends Shock Trooper creating very nice alternating white spaces between the red lines. It makes the Shock Trooper look exactly like the character we saw in the film. Trust us, if you compare the 2006 TSC Skirmish In The Senate Battle Packs Shock Trooper against any subsequently released Shock Trooper, you will be impressed how much better this enhancement looks! And thankfully Hasbro has carried forward the corrected version ever since. Hasbro colored him in a very deep shade of red so he doesn't come across as too bright. The figure looks great and we can never add enough to army build in our collections.

It is interesting to us that this Legacy Collection product contains 75% of its figures that are also available as Legacy Collection Saga Legends individual carded figures too. At $7.99 a pop, it is certainly the better deal to pay $24.99 for the four figures in this Battle Packs set versus getting the four basic carded figures separately. But we would also like to make the point of why Hasbro would be revisiting these figures again in a new format when they are shipping so heavily as basic figures concurrently? We don't know, but it doesn't take away how great the package looks and what a deal it is. And it will provide those of you who have missed out on Emperor Palpatine a new chance to pick him up. (But as this point, we would be shocked if you still needed this figure.) We do like the new approach to Hasbro's Battle Packs, even if they are repeating the same old figures. If you don't need them, it is an easy set to pass on but if you do need some or all, it is a great way to kill multiple birds with one stone. Plus, the presentation is great! And since this Battle Packs set is based on probably the most important duel in the Star Wars saga, it makes sense that it has been captured in a "screen scene" type of platform or medium. While not all Battle Packs are scene-specific, they do a good job of capturing four characters from a film that surround themselves around a certain main battle or action sequence. Emperor Palpatine and a Shock Trooper obviously never looked on as Darth Vader and Obi-Wan Kenobi engaged in battle, but they all appeared on Mustafar at some point. It's technically splitting hairs, but it's true and makes these sets movie source specific enough for us.

Collector Notes

Duel On Mustafar

Assortment Number: 91807/87752

UPC: 653569428053

Retail: $24.99 USD

Market Value: Click here to check the latest prices based on Click here to check the market value on eBay! listings.

Emperor Palpatine

Palpatine flies to Mustafar and brings the gravely wounded Vader to an Imperial rehabilitation facility for treatment.

Status: Emperor Palpatine is a repack of 2005's ROTS Emperor Palpatine (III 12) figure.

Articulation Count: 8 points

Articulation Details: ball-jointed neck, 2 ball-jointed shoulders, 2 swivel wrists, swivel waist, 2 swivel ankles

Accessory Count: 4

Accessory Details: lightsaber, Force lightning, Force effect, removable hood

Date Stamp: 2004

Darth Vader

No longer Anakin Skywalker, Sith Apprentice Darth Vader rejects Obi-Wan's pleas to turn away from the dark side and attacks Kenobi in a lightsaber duel.

Status: Darth Vader is a repack of 2008's TAC Darth Vader (08 02) figure.

Articulation Count: 14 points

Articulation Details: ball-socket head, 2 ball-jointed shoulders, 2 swivel elbows, 2 swivel wrists, swivel waist, 2 ball-jointed hips, 2 ball-jointed knees, 2 ball-jointed ankles

Accessory Count: 1

Accessory Details: lightsaber

Date Stamp: 2008

Obi-Wan Kenobi

Obi-Wan tries to turn Vader back from the dark side, but he realizes that all is lost and his friend has been consumed by evil.

Status: Obi-Wan Kenobi is a straight repack of 2008's TAC Obi-Wan Kenobi (08 01) figure.

Articulation Count: 14 points

Articulation Details: ball-socket head, 2 ball-socket shoulders, 2 ball-jointed elbows, 2 swivel wrists, ball-jointed torso, 2 ball-jointed hips, 2 ball-jointed knees, 2 ball-jointed ankles

Accessory Count: 1

Accessory Details: lightsaber

Date Stamp: 2008

Shock Trooper

These specialized troopers, who are stationed on Coruscant, accompany Palpatine on his solemn journey to Mustafar.

Status: Shock Trooper is a repack of 2007's TAC Shock Trooper Saga Legends figure.

Articulation Count: 14 points

Articulation Details: ball-socket head, 2 ball-jointed shoulders, 2 ball-jointed elbows, 2 swivel wrists, ball-jointed torso, 2 swivel hips, 2 ball-jointed knees, 2 ball-jointed ankles

Accessory Count: 2

Accessory Details: DC-15 blaster, removable antenna

Date Stamp: 2005

Battle Packs (The Clone Wars [S2]/Legacy Collection) Wave 1
Battle For Endor
Gelagrub Patrol
Geonosis Assault (See TLC Geonosis Assault)
Rishi Moon Outpost Attack

Battle Packs (The Clone Wars [S2]/Legacy Collection) Wave 2
Duel On Mustafar
Kamino Conflict

Battle Packs (The Clone Wars [S2]/Legacy Collection) Wave 3
Resurgence Of The Jedi

Battle Packs (The Clone Wars [S2]/Legacy Collection) Wave 4
Birth Of Darth Vader
Holocron Heist
Jedi Showdown
Tatooine Desert Ambush

Added: December 20, 2009
Category: Legacy Collection
Reviewer: Paul Harrison
blog comments powered by Disqus

Return to Research Droids Reviews Index

-Click HERE to return to the home page-



Follow Us

JTA Info



Gentle Giant

Sideshow Collectibles





Disney Store

Acme Archives


Trading Cards

Store Reports

Research Droids Reviews

Visual Guides

Books & Novels


Star Wars Celebration News

Movie & TV News

Q&A of the Day

Rants & Raves

Special Reports

Action Figures In Action








News Archives

Site Search

Image Use Policy

Privacy Policy

RDR Index

Visual Guide Index

Bantha Skull

Collector's Cantina

Imperial Shipyards

Jedi News


Star Wars Action News

Star Wars Figuren

Star Wars New Zealand



Star Wars is a Copyright and Trademark of LucasFilm LTD. This site is intended for informational purposes only, and is not in anyway associated with LFL. All Visual Guides, images, and content are the property of, © 2004-2014 and may not be reused without permission. Please do not direct link to any of the content on this web site. PHP-Nuke Copyright © 2004 by Francisco Burzi. This is free software, and you may redistribute it under the GPL. PHP-Nuke comes with absolutely no warranty, for details, see the license. Click here for our complete Privacy Policy. Click here for our Image Use Policy.